I’m going off the topic for this one, just because I thought it was out of control.
So, incase you were all worried (because I know you were), schools have started banning MySpace. Actually, this idea blossomed first here in Michigan this past week! “Tell me more,” you say? Of course!
On the first day of a strict policy banning students at St. Hugo of the Hills Catholic School from using social networking Web sites, administrators and parents were online ferreting out those who had yet to comply.
“You get to know their code names,” Judy Martinek, the school’s office manager, said Friday.
Sister Margaret Van Velzen, principal of the Bloomfield Hills school, said the policy took effect Friday in response to concerns about students posting “nasty things on the Internet,” and as an attempt to keep the children safe.
…St. Hugo has had a policy prohibiting its 773 students from posting offensive or inappropriate comments and pictures on the Web for years, Van Velzen said. But the new policy went a step further by banning students from using MySpace and other similar sites all together. Under the policy, students who refuse to delete their accounts will be suspended.
“People know the difference between using social networking for a good reason and for things that would be hurtful,” Van Velzen said.
Under MySpace rules, children 14 years and younger should not have a presence on the site anyway, but, Van Velzen said, the company does not adequately enforce that, and many students simply lie about their age. St. Hugo students with sites who were caught Friday were told to dismantle them.
So…what? Kids who have a MySpace page get SUSPENDED? Whoa, wait a minute.
Sister Margaret Van Velzen, the school’s principal, claims that in order to thoroughly protect the children from scary sexual predators, MySpace MUST be banned! However, I feel that the argument that “sexual predators” lurk on websites such as MySpace seems to me to be an empty-ish point. Call me sheltered, but the creepers that would have come after me or any other student in my class wouldn’t have found us on MySpace, but would have found us from some other way like while we were walking after dark or something. Sure, MySpace does have sexual predators and other crazies or whatever on it, but so does every other website or chatroom. Hell, so does every grocery store you walk into. Does that mean you can’t go shopping with your mom?
Since we’re on the topic of parents, let’s talk about them some more. Doesn’t this MySpace ban kind of cross the line into parenting? Parents should know how to keep their kids safe, and having a school tell them how to do so is kind of an insult. I think if I had a child in that district, I’d be a slight bit peeved. But the large majority of parents support this! WTF? Where is your ownership of your children, man!
I guess if the argument was that MySpace was disrupting the classroom, I’d maybe buy into it a little more. But I think this is kind of stepping on a few constitutional rights or something (…good to know that I’m putting my Political Science minor to work, right?). I suppose that the whole “private school” thing kind of thwarts that argument in that parents sign their life away when they decide to send their children there. Ok, ok…
Perhaps I’m missing the point. Blah blah blah dangerous internet…something or other. Good idea, school! Take away a valuable learning tool! Maybe instead of focusing on that sort of thing, schools should start creating more effective programs to teach children how to avoid situations in which they may be taken advantage of because I think we all know that D.A.R.E. doesn’t do it. Ripping away an internet website from kids instead of teaching them how to avoid predators is like sending them into the world without the proper resources for it! DOESN’T MAKE SENSE!
Parents back school’s MySpace ban
by Frank Witsil
Detroit Free Press 26 March 2007
Full article at WZZM Grand Rapids
April 8, 2007 at 9:23 pm
I think if I was a student, I would use a non-school e-mail account and change my name on my page. Now I am not a myspace user, but wouldn’t that work? I’m sure I’m not the first kid to think of this. Since when can school tell you what to do when you’re home? I’m be outraged if I was a student, or a parent at this school. Just because we take Myspace away doesn’t mean we take all the nasty, creepy people out of the world. When I was in grade school, I was walking to my friend’s house after school when a man pulled up next to us in a car, flashed us, and told us to get in his car. Yes, we did get away because our parents taught us how to handle a situation like this! I mean this happened in Traverse City, Michigan! Sexual predators are everywhere, and I got attacked walking a short distance to my friend’s house after school! These creepy people exist, and no matter how hard we try, we can’t get rid of them. So, we have to teach our kids how to handle these situations. We can’t shelter kids from everything. I personally don’t even see what the big deal about Myspace and facebook is. I’ve been on facebook for a few years, and I was on Myspace for one, and I didn’t have any problems. This really sucks for these kids. One of my best friends uses Myspace to keep in touch with her family all over the world. What a great resource. Why are we taking it away?
April 8, 2007 at 9:25 pm
[...] Comment [...]
April 15, 2007 at 5:17 pm
Tami, I have enjoyed your postings this semester! As an “older” non-traditional student, it’s been great for me to be in a classroom with younger people so excited about teaching! I’ve also had my eyes opened a bit to this Myspace stuff. My daughter has Facebook,and actually doesn’t want a Myspace right now. I’m not all that familiar with Facebook, but some people say they are safer?? Who knows. I think Myspace is safe if your settings are set to private. I actually just opened a Myspace account very recently just to check it all out. I think it’s a great tool for social networking! In fact, it’s been a great, more personal way, to communicate with my niece in California. Anyway, my rant is related to your post somehow! As a parent, it is my responsibilty, not the schools, to decide what is, and isn’t allowed for my kids! I can’t believe this kind of crap is still happening. I grew up in a very small Christian school that would have done this, but my gosh, that was in the dark ages!!! (about 20+ years ago)Damn I’m getting old! I really enjoyed, and got so much out of the conference yesterday. Technology is only going to keep expanding….we may as well embrace it and use it, not try to stifle it! This kind of goes along with my topic of Instant Messaging…..at least kids are writing! Great post! Kristie
April 15, 2007 at 7:11 pm
Tami,
I love your posts. If we were to give out a “310 Blogger of The Year” award, I would vote for you. Have I sucked up enough yet?
When I came across this post I of course had to comment. As we all know, or atleast most of us, I’m a believer that MySpace does have a space in schools. The Space can be used a a very, like you said, effective learning tool in school. I completely agree with what you said in your posts about it being the parents responsibility to keep their kids on track when it comes to the internet. I feel like everyone has to be smart on the internet. It’s obvious to me, but apparently not to everyone (schools), that you need to be smart about what you do online. You obviously shouldn’t “friend” a stripper on MySpace nor should you email some random advertisment you get in your account. I also, however, think that it should be some of the teachers responsibility too. Not completely, of course, but if the teachers were to use MySpace in the classroom they would need to keep a close eye on the students. I guess my main issue is that, YES the internet CAN be a dangerous space – but so can driving a car or going to school in the first place. Remember all those school shootings a while ago? The government isn’t banning school is it? Why should we ban something that we DO have the power to control in the schools and use for good? I just don’t understand.
April 15, 2007 at 8:01 pm
[...] 3) Comment to Tami on “We may not be able to pass a standardized test…” [...]
April 15, 2007 at 10:20 pm
I find the suspension of students for having myspace profiles to be utterly ridiculous. Not all myspace profiles contain “dirty” and “inappropriate” content – some kids just have profiles because they’re fun to create and customize, and provide a fun way to communicate with their friends. Personally, I have a myspace account, and I love being able to change the layout of it all of the time and change the song on my profile – I don’t use it to display anything inappropriate, and I doubt that the majority of students who have them use them for that purpose either. Now, I know that some of the problems the schools have is not with what the students do with their profiles, but with what other people use the social network for, i.e, getting in contact with children for sexual reasons. But I find this argument to be flawed as well. Students can customize it so that there profile is only accessible to their friends, and if they choose not to that, and they do receive an inappropriate message, they can simply ignore it. I also have a problem with the ban on myspace because of the education opportunities that myspace could provide. I love the idea of making myspace profiles for the different character in works of literature. It’s a new and fun way for students to learn – myspace shouldn’t be banned altogether.
April 15, 2007 at 10:21 pm
[...] http://tamiteshima.wordpress.com/2007/03/30/we-may-not-be-able-to-pass-a-standardized-test-but-dont-... [...]
April 17, 2007 at 2:47 am
Honestly, how stupid can some schools get… Yes, I understand that bad things have happened on MySpace, but, as seen at the Bright Ideas Conference, it can be used for the greater good. Although I think that MySpace can be used for good in the classroom, I think that there has to be in some limit. Mind you, the school that is suspending students is a Catholic school, and they tend to be a little more strict when it comes to the internet and what their students are allowed to see and do online. It would be a lot better if there weren’t sick people out there and then we wouldn’t have to worry about all this jazz…